Water: Planning
Resources & PerformancePlanningDefinitions/Contacts for FY 2010 National Water Program Guidance Measures: Subobjective: Restore and Protect the South Florida EcosystemDefinitions/Contacts for FY 2010 National Water Program Guidance Measures: Subobjective: Restore and Protect the South Florida Ecosystem
Measure Code: SP-45
Measure Language: Achieve “no net loss” of stony coral cover (mean percent stony coral cover) in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary (FKNMS) and in the coastal waters of Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach Counties, Florida, working with all stakeholders (federal, state, regional, tribal, and local).
Type of Measure: Target measure; Annually reported
Measure Contacts: Steve Blackburn, EPA Region 4
blackburn.steven@epa.gov | (404) 562-9397;
Bill Kruczynski, EPA Region 4
kruczyski.bill@epa.gov | (561) 310-9145
Measure Definition
Terms and Phrases: Stony corals (scleractinians) make up the largest order of corals and are the group primarily responsible for laying the foundations of, and building up, reef structures.
Methodology for Computation of Results: The Florida Keys Coral Reef Evaluation and Monitoring Project (CREMP) was initiated in 1995 to provide data on status and trends of coral habitat in the FKNMS. The major criteria for monitoring the coral reefs included determining the sanctuary-wide spatial coverage of the coral communities, repeatedly surveying them, and statistically documenting the status and trends of the coral communities.
Percent cover of live coral is determined annually from video transects filmed at each monitoring site. Abutting frames with minimal overlap are extracted form a mosaic and analyzed using a custom software application called Point Count for coral reefs.
FY 2010 results will reflect FY 2009 data.
Units: Percent stony coral cover
Universe: A total of 43 sites are monitored annually to determine percent stony coral cover throughout the FKNMS. The Southeast Coral Reef Evaluation and Monitoring Project was established in 2003 with a total of ten sites to provide data on status and trends of coral habitat in southeast Florida (coastal waters of Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach Counties).
Baseline: The baseline for stony coral cover for the FKNMS and southeast Florida is 2005.
Measure Code: SP-46
Measure Language: Annually, maintain the overall health and functionality of seagrass beds in the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary (FKNMS) as measured by the long-term seagrass monitoring project that addresses composition and abundance, productivity, and nutrient availability.
Type of Measure: Target measure; Annually reported
Measure Contacts: Steve Blackburn, EPA Region 4
blackburn.steven@epa.gov | (404) 562-9397;
Bill Kruczynski, EPA Region 4
kruczyski.bill@epa.gov | (561) 310-9145
Measure Definition
Terms and Phrases: Thalassia is the dominant species of seagrass within the Florida Key National Marine Sanctuary (FKNMS).
Methodology for Computation of Results: The Seagrass Monitoring Project (SMP) for the FKNMS was initiated in 1995 and uses the rapid visual assessment technique known as the Braun-Blanquet method to measure benthic plant community structure. This method is quick, yet robust and highly repeatable, thereby minimizing among-observer differences. A summary metric or species composition indicator (SCI) that assesses the relative importance of slow-growing plants to community composition is computed for the 30 permanent seagrass monitoring sites throughout the FKNMS. The 30 sites are sampled quarterly. The seagrass indicator is based on species composition of seagrass beds. During the first 10 years of monitoring, the SCI had an average of .48. Any decrease in this SCI is interpreted as a decrease in water quality in the FKNMS. The SMP also assesses seagrass nutrient availability using tissue concentration assays. Elemental content (nitrogen/N and phosphorus/P) of seagrass leaves is determined by cleaning the leaves of all epiphytes, drying the leaves at low temperature, and grinding to a fine powder. Elemental content is then measured using established methods. A summary elemental content indicator measure or elemental indicator (EI), which is the mean absolute deviation of N:P ratio of seagrass tissue from 30:1 is computed for the 30 permanent monitoring sites. The long-term average mean absolute difference in the N:P of Thalassia leaves at the 30 monitoring sites 8.3. A decrease in EI from the long-term average will indicate a decrease in water quality.
Success for this measure is achieved if both the species composition indicator and elemental indicator are maintained.
FY 2010 results will reflect FY 2009 data.
Units: Both SCI and EI are unit less measures.
Universe: 30 permanent seagrass monitoring sites throughout the FKNMS.
Baseline: The baseline for SCI and EI for the FKNMS is 2005.
Measure Code: SP-47
Measure Language: Annually, maintain the overall water quality of the near shore and coastal waters of the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary (FKNMS).
Type of Measure: Target measure; Annually reported
Measure Contacts: Steve Blackburn, EPA Region 4
blackburn.steven@epa.gov | (404) 562-9397;
Bill Kruczynski, EPA Region 4
kruczyski.bill@epa.gov | (561) 310-9145
Measure Definition
Terms and Phrases:
Methodology for Computation of Results: The Water Quality Monitoring Project (WQMP) was initiated in 1995 and samples and data are collected quarterly from 154 stations throughout the FKNMS. The WQMP uses a stratified random design based upon EPA’s Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program (EMAP) and stations are randomly located along near shore to offshore transects. By stratifying the sampling stations according to depth, distance from shore, proximity to tidal passes, and influence of water masses outside the Florida Keys, the project has been able to report on the relative importance of external versus internal factors affecting the ambient water quality within the FKNMS. Numerous (about 18) physical and chemical water quality parameters are tracked by the WQMP. However, for purposes of strategic measures, only four critical water quality metrics are considered. For reef stations, chlorophyll less than or equal to 0.2 micrograms/liter (ug/l) and vertical attenuation coefficient for downward irradiance (Kd, i.e., light attenuation) less than or equal to 0.13 per meter; for all stations in the FKNMS, dissolved inorganic nitrogen less than or equal to 0.75 micromolar and total phosphorus less than or equal to 0.2 micromolar; water quality within these limits is considered essential to promote coral growth and overall health. The “number of samples” exceeding these targets is tracked and reported annually.
Because water quality data are not normally distributed, the project uses the median as the measure of central tendency. Success for this measure is achieved if at least 2 of the 4 critical water quality metrics are maintained.
FY 2010 results will reflect FY 2009 data.
Units: Water Quality
Universe: 154 stations throughout the FKNMS.
Baseline: The 2005 baseline for each water quality metric is as follows: chlorophyll - 43 sites; light attenuation - 23 sites; dissolved inorganic nitrogen - 54 sites; and total phosphorus - 63 sites.
Measure Code: SP-48
Measure Language: Improve the water quality of the Everglades ecosystem as measured by total phosphorus, including meeting the 10 parts per billion (ppb) total phosphorus criterion throughout the Everglades Protection Area marsh and the effluent limits to be established for discharges from Stormwater Treatment Areas.
Type of Measure: Target measure; Annually reported
Measure Contact: Dan Scheidt; EPA Region 4
scheidt.dan@epa.gov | (706) 355-8724;
Steve Blackburn, EPA Region 4
blackburn.steven@epa.gov | (404) 562-9397
Measure Definition
Terms and Phrases: The Everglades has been subjected to phosphorus pollution since the 1960s. Interior Everglades marshes removed from anthropogenic nutrient sources have extremely low total phosphorus (TP) concentrations in surface water, as low as the method detection limit of 2 parts per billion (ppb). Phosphorus loading in stormwater from the Everglades Agricultural Area (EAA) and urban areas has significantly increased phosphorus concentrations in the downstream Everglades (as high as 100 ppb), causing eutrophic impacts to these oligotrophic wetlands. Among the progressive eutrophic impacts are altered periphyton communities, loss of water column dissolved oxygen, increased soil phosphorus content, conversion of the native wet prairie-sawgrass mosaic to dense single-species stands of cattail with no open water, and consequent loss of wading bird foraging habitat. These collective changes impact the structure and function of the aquatic ecosystem. By 1990 over 40,000 acres of the public Everglades were estimated to be impacted.
In 2005, Florida adopted and EPA approved a 10 ppb water quality criterion for TP in the Everglades in order to prevent nutrient-induced imbalances in natural populations of aquatic flora or fauna. The criterion is applied as a long-term average, with achievement of the criterion within the Everglades waterbody determined by data collected monthly at fixed long-term marsh sampling locations.
A phosphorus control program was initiated in the 1990s in order to prevent further loss of Everglades plant communities and wildlife habitat due to phosphorus enrichment. Control is to be achieved by agricultural Best Management Practices along with about 47,000 acres of constructed treatment wetlands within the EAA, referred to as Stormwater Treatment Areas (STAs). This $1 billion effort to treat large volumes of stormwater down to 10 ppb TP is unprecedented. STAs have permits (NPDES and /or Florida Everglades Forever Act) with TP discharge limits.
Units: Water quality
Universe: See above.
Baseline: Average annual geometric mean phosphorus concentrations were 5 ppb in Everglades National Park, 10 ppb in Water Conservation Area 3A, 13 ppb in Loxahatchee National Wildlife Refuge, and 18 ppb in Water Conservation Area 2A. Annual average flow - weighted total phosphorus discharges from Stormwater Treatment Areas ranges from 13ppb for area ¾ and 98 ppb for area 1W. (2005)